49:
LOOP bugs reported by Peter Van Eynde July 25, 2000:
- a: (LOOP WITH (A B) DO (PRINT 1)) is a syntax error according to
- the definition of WITH clauses given in the ANSI spec, but
- compiles and runs happily in SBCL.
b: a messy one involving package iteration:
interpreted Form: (LET ((PACKAGE (MAKE-PACKAGE "LOOP-TEST"))) (INTERN "blah" PACKAGE) (LET ((BLAH2 (INTERN "blah2" PACKAGE))) (EXPORT BLAH2 PACKAGE)) (LIST (SORT (LOOP FOR SYM BEING EACH PRESENT-SYMBOL OF PACKAGE FOR SYM-NAME = (SYMBOL-NAME SYM) COLLECT SYM-NAME) (FUNCTION STRING<)) (SORT (LOOP FOR SYM BEING EACH EXTERNAL-SYMBOL OF PACKAGE FOR SYM-NAME = (SYMBOL-NAME SYM) COLLECT SYM-NAME) (FUNCTION STRING<))))
Should be: (("blah" "blah2") ("blah2"))
but actual specification quoted above says that the actual behavior
is undefined.
+125:
+ (as reported by Gabe Garza on cmucl-help 2001-09-21)
+ (defvar *tmp* 3)
+ (defun test-pred (x y)
+ (eq x y))
+ (defun test-case ()
+ (let* ((x *tmp*)
+ (func (lambda () x)))
+ (print (eq func func))
+ (print (test-pred func func))
+ (delete func (list func))))
+ Now calling (TEST-CASE) gives output
+ NIL
+ NIL
+ (#<FUNCTION {500A9EF9}>)
+ Evidently Python thinks of the lambda as a code transformation so
+ much that it forgets that it's also an object.
+
+126:
+ (reported by Dan Barlow sbcl-devel 2001-09-26)
+ * (defun s () (make-string 10 :initial-element #\Space))
+ S
+ * (s)
+ " "
+ * (compile 's)
+ S
+ NIL
+ NIL
+ * (s)
+ "" <- ten ASCII NULs
+ But other, non-#\Space values of INITIAL-ELEMENT work OK.
+
+
KNOWN BUGS RELATED TO THE IR1 INTERPRETER
-(Note: At some point, the pure interpreter (actually a semi-pure
-interpreter aka "the IR1 interpreter") will probably go away, replaced
-by constructs like
- (DEFUN EVAL (X) (FUNCALL (COMPILE NIL (LAMBDA ..)))))
-and at that time these bugs should either go away automatically or
-become more tractable to fix. Until then, they'll probably remain,
-since some of them aren't considered urgent, and the rest are too hard
-to fix as long as so many special cases remain. After the IR1
-interpreter goes away is also the preferred time to start
-systematically exterminating cases where debugging functionality
-(backtrace, breakpoint, etc.) breaks down, since getting rid of the
-IR1 interpreter will reduce the number of special cases we need to
-support.)
-
-IR1-1:
- The FUNCTION special operator doesn't check properly whether its
- argument is a function name. E.g. (FUNCTION (X Y)) returns a value
- instead of failing with an error. (Later attempting to funcall the
- value does cause an error.)
-
-IR1-2:
- COMPILED-FUNCTION-P bogusly reports T for interpreted functions:
- * (DEFUN FOO (X) (- 12 X))
- FOO
- * (COMPILED-FUNCTION-P #'FOO)
- T
-
-IR1-3:
- Executing
- (DEFVAR *SUPPRESS-P* T)
- (EVAL '(UNLESS *SUPPRESS-P*
- (EVAL-WHEN (:COMPILE-TOPLEVEL :LOAD-TOPLEVEL :EXECUTE)
- (FORMAT T "surprise!"))))
- prints "surprise!". Probably the entire EVAL-WHEN mechanism ought to be
- rewritten from scratch to conform to the ANSI definition, abandoning
- the *ALREADY-EVALED-THIS* hack which is used in sbcl-0.6.8.9 (and
- in the original CMU CL source, too). This should be easier to do --
- though still nontrivial -- once the various IR1 interpreter special
- cases are gone.
-
-IR1-3a:
- EVAL-WHEN's idea of what's a toplevel form is even more screwed up
- than the example in IR1-3 would suggest, since COMPILE-FILE and
- COMPILE both print both "right now!" messages when compiling the
- following code,
- (LAMBDA (X)
- (COND (X
- (EVAL-WHEN (:COMPILE-TOPLEVEL :LOAD-TOPLEVEL :EXECUTE)
- (PRINT "yes! right now!"))
- "yes!")
- (T
- (EVAL-WHEN (:COMPILE-TOPLEVEL :LOAD-TOPLEVEL :EXECUTE)
- (PRINT "no! right now!"))
- "no!")))
- and while EVAL doesn't print the "right now!" messages, the first
- FUNCALL on the value returned by EVAL causes both of them to be printed.
+(Now that the IR1 interpreter has gone away, these should be
+relatively straightforward to fix.)
IR1-4:
The system accepts DECLAIM in most places where DECLARE would be
projects / sbcl.git / blobdiff